Exposé Online banner

Exposé Online

Not just outside the box, but denying the existence of boxes.
Covering music from the fringes since 1993.

Reviews

The John Sally Ride — For Sal
(Think Like a Key TLAK1251, 2026, CD / DL)

by Henry Schneider, Published 2026-11-19

For Sal Cover art

When I first encountered the name The John Sally Ride, my immediate assumption was that it somehow referred to astronaut Sally Ride. Given how that story ended, that would have been in spectacularly poor taste. Fortunately, the explanation is far less provocative: the band's name is simply a combination of John Dunbar and the two Sals, drummer Sal Nunziato and bassist Sal Maida. The John Sally Ride is not some legendary power-pop institution finally paying tribute to a founding member. Rather, it was a relatively obscure project formed by three friends, one of whom happened to have played briefly with Roxy Music, Sparks, and Milk 'n' Cookies several decades earlier. For Sal is essentially John Dunbar's musical memorial to that friend. The group's previous releases, A New Set of Downs and Nothing Doing, passed largely beneath the radar, and little here suggests that For Sal will fare differently. Conceived after Maida's death in 2025, the album chronicles his life through ten original songs covering everything from his Little Italy upbringing to his days with Roxy Music and Sparks, his travels, his musical friendships, and even the concerts he attended. The problem is not that Sal Maida was unworthy of a tribute. His resumé is respectable enough within power-pop and glam-rock circles. The problem is that the album assumes listeners already care. Most won't. Song after song unfolds like a chapter summary from a memoir, recounting events without ever giving them broader meaning. A successful tribute should make listeners care about its subject. For Sal never clears that hurdle. Musically, the material rarely rises above competent power pop. The bigger obstacle is Dunbar's vocal delivery. His thin, nasal singing dominates nearly every track, steadily wearing down whatever charm the melodies might otherwise possess. Even guest appearances that seem promising on paper fail to register. Phil Manzanera's appearance on "Stranded after Touring Stranded" should have been a selling point, yet his contribution leaves little lasting impression amid the relentlessly twee presentation. The packaging follows the same misguided philosophy. The booklet provides all the lyrics, but each page is overloaded with photographs, maps, tickets, memorabilia, and visual references connected to Maida's life. Rather than enhancing the songs, the design reinforces the feeling that listeners are being asked to admire someone else's scrapbook. The lone exception is "Oh! The Shows He Has Seen," which at least approaches a subject with wider appeal. Most serious music fans can relate to the thrill of discovering artists and accumulating memorable concert experiences. Unfortunately, one reasonably successful song cannot carry an entire album. Think Like a Key has built a reputation by rescuing overlooked recordings and reissuing worthwhile obscurities. This release misses the mark. For Sal may be a heartfelt tribute among friends, but as an album intended for public consumption, it offers little reason for anyone outside that circle to listen, and even less reason to come back.


Filed under: New releases, 2026 releases

Related artist(s): Phil Manzanera, The John Sally Ride

More info
http://shop.thinklikeakey.com/release/the-john-sally-ride-for-sal/

 

What's new

These are the most recent changes made to artists, releases, and articles.