Exposé print issues (1993-2011)
Alex Wroten — Weird Christmas
(Think Like a Key no#, 2026, LP / DL)
by Henry Schneider, Published 2026-11-17
From the crazed gaze on the album cover to the reconstructed and frequently unrecognizable versions of familiar Christmas songs within, Weird Christmas may be one of the strangest holiday albums I have ever encountered. Composer, producer, and multi-instrumentalist Alex Wroten takes thirteen beloved Christmas standards and subjects them to a process of musical deconstruction that ranges from intriguing to baffling. The comparison that kept coming to mind was Morgan Fisher's Hybrid Kids Claws project. Like Fisher, Wroten takes familiar material apart and reassembles it into unexpected new forms. Unlike Fisher, however, Wroten rarely seems interested in fun. Where Claws was playful, witty, and often laugh-out-loud funny, Weird Christmas is frequently dark, unsettling, and oddly confrontational. The album opens with "Bells," beginning with what sounds like a small child asking, "Mommy, do Jingle Bells." Any expectation of a traditional rendition is immediately discarded. Percussive breathing sounds, chimes, and bells introduce a minor-key landscape where only fleeting traces of "Jingle Bells" eventually emerge. "Angels We Have Heard While High" continues the approach, employing a psych-prog sensibility filled with unexpected intervals and harmonic detours. Just when the listener starts to recognize the carol, Wroten throws another curveball. By "God Rest Ye Canceled Gentlemen," a throbbing bass line, ambient chords, and male and female vocal layers create the sense that multiple musical ideas are competing for attention. "O Weihnachtsbaum" ventures even further afield, becoming a dark, pulsating instrumental driven by metallic percussion and syncopated organ that bears almost no resemblance to "O Christmas Tree." If heard out of context, few listeners would ever identify its origins. Things become even stranger with "The Twelve Days of Pathological Overgifting." Distorted fragments of the original melody lurk beneath a throbbing bass and sinister chanting. At this point I found myself repeatedly asking not what song I was hearing, but why Wroten was doing this at all. What point was he trying to make? That question persisted through "Away," which takes “Away in a Manger” and “Silent Night” and subjects them to distorted glissandos and radical rearrangements that reveal only occasional glimpses of the source material. One begins to wonder whether Wroten actively dislikes Christmas music, Christianity, or the traditions behind these songs. Yet the very existence of the album argues otherwise. This feels less like hatred than a fascination with dismantling expectations. The second half of the album provides only occasional relief. "Up on the Housetop Scaring the Neighbors" offers a pleasant cinematic introduction and female vocals, though it remains slow and somewhat plodding. "W3K Bug" is one of the more enjoyable tracks, beginning as a fast-paced instrumental before introducing a distorted version of "We Three Kings." I found myself wondering whether an electric sitar was being used, adding a psychedelic flavor largely absent elsewhere. "O Holy Nightclub" returns to more challenging territory. Female vocals move through twisted intervals that often seem to work against the accompaniment rather than with it. The result is deliberately unsettling but never entirely satisfying. "Deck Out the Halls" comes closest to capturing the spirit of Morgan Fisher's experiments, presenting an instrumental minor-key transformation of "Deck the Halls" that feels genuinely playful. "Sample and Deploy to the World" electronically manipulates and fragments the vocals of "Joy to the World," while "We Conditionally Wish You a Merry Christmas" finally reveals some of the humor that has been largely missing from the proceedings. Its sped-up vocals create a bizarre atmosphere that reminded me of the Three Stooges crashing through a Christmas pageant and wrecking the scenery. The album closes with "The Last Noel," a slow, mournful arrangement built around piano and violin. It is about as far removed from welcoming Jesus into the world as one could imagine. Rather than ending with joy, wonder, or celebration, the album concludes on a somber, almost funereal note. There is no questioning Wroten's creativity. He succeeds admirably in making familiar Christmas songs unfamiliar. The problem is that Weird Christmas often feels more committed to being strange than to being enjoyable. While Claws invited listeners into the joke, Weird Christmas sometimes seems determined to test their patience. The arrangements are inventive, and several tracks can stand on their own as interesting compositions, but the album repeatedly strips these carols of the very qualities that made them beloved in the first place. Weird Christmas is certainly not your mama's Christmas music. Whether that is a recommendation or a warning depends entirely on your tolerance for musical deconstruction, irreverence, and sustained weirdness. By the end, I was left less impressed by what Wroten had done to these songs than puzzled by why he felt compelled to do it. That lingering question may be the album's greatest achievement, or its greatest flaw.
Filed under: New releases, 2026 releases
Related artist(s): The Gatekeepers (Alex Wroten)
More info
http://thinklikeakey.bandcamp.com/album/weird-christmas
These are the most recent changes made to artists, releases, and articles.