Exposé Online banner

Discipline — Push & Profit
(Strung Out Records 128764-01, 1993, CD)

by Dan Casey, Published 1994-02-01

Push & Profit Cover artDiscipline are a young five-piece band from Detroit, Michigan, whose instrumentation includes the usual bass/drums/keys/guitars with the fifth and front man doing vocals/violin/keys/guitar. While they unashamedly borrow their name from King Crimson, as well as cite Crimson, Zappa, Yes and Gentle Giant as major influences, they end up sounding nothing like Crimson at all really. The overall sound is more like Peter Gabriel, Marillion, Pink Floyd and Gentle Giant. Push & Profit is a 1993-recorded collection of eight songs written between 1987 and 1992. Each song on this album is remarkably separable from the others, each offering a distinct and different style that the band is capable of. Unfortunately, the end result is an album of some tracks that are always worth listening to and some that are always worth skipping over. The best tracks are the Gabriel-esque "Diminished," the Floydian "Systems" and the obviously Giant-influenced "The Reasoning Wall," by far the best track on the album. This song has a strong verse melody with some unique intervals, and lively counterpoint instrumental break in the middle. Clearly, the drummer and keyboard player are the best musicians in the band, and this song shows that Discipline is capable of writing some complex and fascinating music full of neat time and tempo changes when they put their minds to it. In fact, its not too hard to imagine this song being performed by Giant themselves! However, some of the other tracks on the album show that the band is unclear about their direction. A couple of the tunes have little to do with progressive at all, really. The inconsistency in the music is paralleled by an inconsistency in the lyrics too, but fortunately when the music is at its best, so are the lyrics. The album seems to lack energy when taken as a whole, since many of the tempi are very slow, but taken in small chunks, this flaw isn't so obvious. The production and engineering are totally professional, well above what many other independent bands have put together for their first release. The lack of consistency is the biggest hurdle the band still has to overcome and because of that, Push & Profit is definitely not one for the "highly recommended" category. But because of songs like "Systems" and "The Reasoning Wall," it is an album (and a band) certainly worth a listen.

Filed under: New releases, Issue 2, 1993 releases

Related artist(s): Discipline

Latest news

2017-02-20
Larry Coryell RIP – One of the greats of jazz guitar has left us at the age of 73. Larry Coryell was one of the founding figures of jazz fusion, but produced a significant body of work the bridged many styles. His group Eleventh House provided a unique take on the combination of jazz and rock that was distinct from contemporaries such as Mahavishnu Orchestra, Return to Forever, and Weather Report. » Read more

2017-01-31
John Wetton RIP – After a long battle with colon cancer, singer and bassist John Wetton has died at the age of 67. As an integral member of such bands as King Crimson, UK, and Asia, his was one of the distinctive voices in progressive rock, lending a human touch to often difficult music. » Read more

2017-01-30
Seaprog Announces First Artists for 2017 – The organizers of the Seaprog Festival in Seattle have announced the first set of confirmed performers for the 2017 festival. The best known names are Cabezas de Cera and Jack o' the Clock, but a host of other bands are featured, mostly from the Northwest. The festival will take place June 2-4, 2017. » Read more

2017-01-27
Acoustic Festival of Britain 2017 Announces Eclectic Lineup – The Acoustic Festival of Britain has been going since 2006, and this year's event sees a number of outstanding artists on the bill. Fairport Convention, Tir na nOg, and Martin Turner are some of the artists we've covered, and there are many more, including The Men They Couldn't Hang, Howard Jones, Chantel McGregor, and many more. The festival runs June 2-4, 2017 at Uttoxeter Racecourse in Staffordshire. » Read more

2017-01-26
Butch Trucks RIP – Butch Trucks was one of two drummers in the first incarnation of the Allman Brothers Band in 1969, helping the band achieve its legendary status as an American original. He died on January 24, 2017 of a self-inflicted gunshot would. He was 69. » Read more


Previously in Exposé...

Thinking Plague - A History of Madness – Most music critics (and listeners too) tend to get caught up in the genre game when describing music. We think in terms of qualities like loud/soft, electric/acoustic, rocks/doesn’t. But there...  (2003) » Read more



Listen & discover



Print issues