Exposé Online banner

Various Artists — Eyewitness - A Tribute to VdGG
(Mellow MMP 279 A/B, 1995, 2CD)

by Peter Thelen, Published 1996-03-01

Eyewitness - A Tribute to VdGG Cover art

This one made it in just under the wire, finding release in the fading days of December. The fact that (at least in the USA) Van der Graaf Generator is not the household word that, say Genesis, Yes, and Pink Floyd are – and the fact that they had enough sense to call it a day before they made a major move toward commercialism – makes this tribute perhaps the most interesting of the lot. The material spans all of VdGG’s career, as well as some solo Peter Hammill tracks. Disc one kicks off with Landberk’s rendition of “Afterwards” – it’s immediately obvious they were the perfect band to cover that track. Anyone who has ever heard either of TNR’s albums knows well that Peter Hammill is a major influence, so who better to turn in a cover of “Last Frame”? Those who remember Alberto Piras from Progfest ‘95, the powerful and acrobatic lead vocalist with Deus Ex Machina will be happy to know they’ve offered an eight minute version of “After the Flood,” which is one of the album’s finest performances. Gizmo’s “House with No Door,” Germinale’s take on World Record’s “Meurglys III,” and Irrgarten’s “Still Life” are all solid and respectable performances from disc one, but French TV’s fourteen minute rendition of “Pioneers over C” adds a whole new dimension to that classic tune. But nobody did “Plague of Lighthouse Keepers”! Oh well... In fact the only noticeably weak track on the first disc is “Refugees” by Finisterre – a nice enough arrangement, but it’s the harsh vocals that do it in. Otherwise the entire first disc is a winner.

First up on the second disc is Epicentro, a band I’ve never heard of, covering “Lemmings.” Up to this point poor pronuciation of lyrics (like that which plagued many of the tunes on Mellow’s Genesis tribute set) has not been a problem, but here it appears for the first time. Also, the band sounds a little under-rehearsed at times. We continue onward with a cover of “Necromancer” by Luna Inconstante, followed by offerings from duo Nostalgia, Notturno Concertante, Art and Illusion, and Twenty Four Hours – the latter being another new name. Egoband’s “Arrow” is the only track pulled from Godbluff (What?! No "Sleepwalkers"?), a decent enough rendition, but as it goes, not that earth-shaking either. Men of Lake, a four piece that’s been around for some time and operates in a very-70s mode, has done an impressive cover of “Killer”; their tortured sounding vocalist is a perfect complement to Hammill, and this in fact may be the best track from the second disc. Jay Tausig’s Mellotron-drenched “Solitude,” followed by an essentialy solo “On Tuesday's Slender Threads,” is another standout from disc two. Overall, this is a worthwhile set, and one worth owning. I guess the fact that so much of Van der Graaf’s original material was solid to begin with (they never really cheesed out like Genesis and Yes), while remaining relatively simple to play, makes this one of the better tribute sets this year.


Filed under: New releases, Issue 9, 1995 releases

Related artist(s): Germinale, Peter Hammill, Van der Graaf Generator, Deus Ex Machina, Finisterre, Jay Tausig, French TV, Landberk, Various Artists, Irrgarten, Zauber, Men of Lake, Reine Fiske

More info
http://mellowrecords.bandcamp.com/album/vdgg-tribute-eyewitness-2cd

Latest news

2020-03-24
Bill Rieflin RIP – The sad news reaches us today of Bill Rieflin's death. Rieflin was best known as a drummer in bands ranging from post-punk to industrial to indie-rock to progressive rock, including work with The Blackouts, Ministry, Nine Inch Nails, Swans, Land, and King Crimson. Rieflin had been battling cancer for several years, and succumbed to it on March 24. He was 59. » Read more

2020-03-17
Cruise to the Edge and Seaprog 2020 Festivals Postponed – The worldwide outbreak of the novel coronavirus has started to produce casualties in the music world, and festivals are not immune. We've had word that both the Cruise to the Edge (originally slated for March 27 - April 1) and Seaprog (originally June 5-7) have been postponed to later dates, with those dates to be announced. » Read more

2020-03-06
McCoy Typer RIP – Word reaches us today of the passing of one of the most influential pianists in the history of jazz, McCoy Tyner. His tenure with John Coltrane in the early 60s includes some of the most treasured recordings of the era, including My Favorite Things and A Love Supreme. After leaving Coltrane's group, he had a long and successful solo career. He was 81. » Read more

2020-02-18
Jon Christensen RIP – Word reaches us today of the passing of Norwegian drummer Jon Christensen, a musician whose sensitive playing did much to help define the atmospheric sound of ECM jazz recordings. His work with Jan Garbarek, Bobo Stenson, Terje Rypdal, and many more was sensitive and varied, adapting to a wide variety of styles while maintaining a distinct identity of its own. Christensen was 76. » Read more

2020-01-21
Gong Announces UK Tour for 2020 – Having spent the last few years touring the world, including dates in Japan with psych legend Steve Hillage, multiple headline European tours and festivals, America’s Cruise to the Edge festival, a South America headline tour, and a headline performance at Tomorrow Festival in China, the band have won the hearts of both traditional and modern Gong fanbases. During this live journey, Gong has delved further into the truly psychedelic, exploratory, and mind-expanding side of the music. » Read more


Previously in Exposé...

Algernon - Ghost Surveillance – Lately I've been listening to a lot of music that is labeled "post-rock," and like many genre labels, there is a point at which it becomes meaningless. World's End Girlfriend, GYBE,...  (2011) » Read more



Listen & discover



Print issues