Gentle Giant — Out of the Woods - The BBC Sessions
(Band of Joy BOJCD 018, 1975/1996, CD)
by Jeff Melton,
Published 1997-02-01

Here is another BBC sessions release on the Band of Joy label, with one
unreleased track and several earlier versions of arrangements which
became live staples of the band during the group's heyday. "City
Hermit" is the only one of three unreleased tracks recovered and included from the band's first session in 1970. It's very much in the same vein as the first album material: heavy organ passages with simple lyrical
content. "Way of Life" is a track from the
In a Glass House album
from 1973 which doesn't hold up well. It is clear the band was having
some difficulty in translating some studio material to live performance in this attempt, but it's still quite listenable.
Some pretty weird guitar parts from Gary Green in there! An early
arrangement of the three-plus song medley from
Octopus is revealing in that
you can visualize the approach the band (mostly Kerry Minnear, keyboard
mastermind/arranger) was utilizing to segue tracks together. Interjected
into this entertaining hodgepodge is an engaging acoustic guitar intro
for "Boys in the Band" (later dropped in the live version to be replaced by "Acquiring the Taste") and also the recorder trio performing "Yankee
Doodle." Most of the remainder of the tracks come from the band's
peak creative period:
The Power and the Glory and
Free Hand, all of which
are outstanding slightly alternate versions. Keyboard textures are
different than from studio versions too: instrument of choice is
different in switching parts from organ to synth, piano to organ etc.;
the guitar playing is a bit more aggressive and edgy which was also
one of Gary Green's strengths. Sleeve notes are by international fan
club president Geir Hasnes, who must be singled out as key
researcher/fan of note to try bring this project together. I'd like to
shake his hand for perseverance in making it happen, since dealing with the
BBC can be such a bureaucratic nightmare especially when trying to
appeal to the "tadpole in the ocean" mentality. For the limited audience,
it's very rewarding to still be able to appreciate the quirky works of
bygone era.
Filed under: New releases, Issue 11, 1996 releases, 1975 recordings
Related artist(s): Gentle Giant