Syrinx — Tumblers from the Vault (1970-1972)
(RVNG Intl. ReRVNG08, 1972/2016, 2CD)
by Jon Davis, Published 2016-10-14
If anyone had any doubts that the late 60s and early 70s were a time of broad innovation and experimentation, this collection provides ample evidence that even outside the cultural centers of New York, London, San Francisco, and Los Angeles, musicians were creating new sounds. Syrinx was a Canadian group formed by keyboard player John Mills-Cockell, saxophonist Doug Pringle, and percussionist Alan Wells, and far from operating within the realm of psychedelic rock or jazz, they produced a wildly original blend of (then) cutting-edge electronics and avant-garde music. The closest comparison might be Silver Apples, though Syrinx is informed much more by classical chamber music than by rock or pop. After recording two albums, the members went their separate ways and their music faded into obscurity. With this collection, RVNG brings together all the previously released material along with some unreleased tracks. It starts off will all of the tracks from Long Lost Relatives, the group’s 1971 second album, followed by the self-titled debut from 1970; the second CD (third LP) contains all of the bonus material. The liner notes are extensive and informative, giving a thorough history of the music at hand.
Long Lost Relatives is the more consistently engaging of the original albums, so starting with it gets things off to a good start. For a modern listener coming to this music, many comparisons come to mind, frequently Cluster & Eno (1977), with its calm sense of melodicism. The percussion is often absent or quite understated, and functions more like orchestral percussion than anything else. “December’s Angel” is a lovely highlight, starting with a meditative Satie-esque keyboard and some electronic noises, then gradually adding a string section and a hint of Vivaldi crossed with Philip Glass. The saxophone comes in finally to emphasize the melody, bringing it to a beautiful close. Throughout the album, it’s clear that Mills-Cockell was not part of any of the electronic streams of the time: not using the synthesizers to imitate conventional instruments (as in Switched-On Bach), not abstract noises (along the lines of Forbidden Planet), and not simply sound effects added to more conventional music for a sense of exoticism or futurism (as in any number of recordings from the time). The music is consistently tonal and doesn’t venture much into dissonance, though many of the synthesizer parts are non-tonal or white-noisy, but the melodicism never comes off as simple-minded or nostalgic.
Syrinx, by contrast, has less in the way of instrumentation, relying on the core trio for all the sounds. Mills-Cockell plays piano, organ, and synthesizers; Pringle’s sax handles some of the melodies; and Wells sticks to gongs and hand percussion. This album started as a set of solo recordings by Mills-Cockell; the sax and percussion were added later, along with reworking some of the original recordings, but it all sounds natural enough that you wouldn’t know how it was created without reading the liner notes. Again, the music anticipates developments nearly ten years in its future. The compositions are deceptively simple, though they feature lush, complex harmonies and masterful use of texture. The sound quality is stellar, and without foreknowledge that it dates from 1969-70, a listener would never guess that it was anywhere near that old.
The highlight of the bonus material is the “Stringspace” suite, recorded live with a chamber orchestra. The four individual sections of the suite all appeared on the studio albums in different forms. This music was commissioned for the Toronto Repertory Ensemble and recorded for a television broadcast. It is testament to Mill-Cockell’s skills and studies in composition that the expanded versions work so well. Aside from the addition of the strings, Wells’ percussion gets a somewhat more prominent role in these versions, and Pringle’s sax work is more assertive. While the fidelity of these live tracks is not up to the standards of the studio albums, they are certainly listenable, and both a glimpse into another side of the band and a taste of what could have been if they had carried on. A particularly interesting bonus track is an alternate version of “Melina’s Torch,” which was the lead-off track of the debut album. There it was less than three minutes long, a pleasant tune with a few intertwining synthesizer parts, subtle bongos, and a sax melody that comes in halfway through. The “solo” version is (I think) the original Mills-Cockell tape. It is nearly ten minutes of fairly sparse synthesizer work, very interesting and experimental. Various bits of it were edited together, and the other musicians added their parts to create the album version. Perhaps less successful — but interesting nonetheless — is the vocal version of “Better Deaf and Dumb from the First,” which was an instrumental track on Long Lost Relatives.
All in all, this is an extraordinary collection, an important side-alley in the history of electronic music. Not only that, but it is eminently listenable, with artistic value in addition to its historical worth. RVNG has done this one right, providing an excellent package for music which deserves attention and respect.
Related artist(s): Syrinx
ProgDay 2017 Announces First Bands – Flor de Loto, Sonar, and Infinien are the first three performers to be announced for the 2017 edition of the long-running ProgDay Festival. The 23rd ProgDay takes place Saturday and Sunday, September 2nd and 3rd, at Storybook Farm in Chapel Hill, North Carolina. » Read more
Allan Holdsworth RIP – Surely in the list of artists who have contributed to the sound of modern music, there is a special spot for guitarist Allan Holdsworth. His name is known to virtually every student of the instrument in jazz and rock, and his style has been so widely emulated that it's hardly worth mentioning anymore — we can just assume that every guitarist has Holdsworth as an influence. » Read more
Larry Coryell RIP – One of the greats of jazz guitar has left us at the age of 73. Larry Coryell was one of the founding figures of jazz fusion, but produced a significant body of work the bridged many styles. His group Eleventh House provided a unique take on the combination of jazz and rock that was distinct from contemporaries such as Mahavishnu Orchestra, Return to Forever, and Weather Report. » Read more
John Wetton RIP – After a long battle with colon cancer, singer and bassist John Wetton has died at the age of 67. As an integral member of such bands as King Crimson, UK, and Asia, his was one of the distinctive voices in progressive rock, lending a human touch to often difficult music. » Read more
Seaprog Announces First Artists for 2017 – The organizers of the Seaprog Festival in Seattle have announced the first set of confirmed performers for the 2017 festival. The best known names are Jack o' the Clock and Zero Times Everything, but a host of other bands are featured, mostly from the Northwest. The festival will take place June 2-4, 2017. » Read more