Exposé Online banner

Gentle Giant — Scraping the Barrel
(Alucard ALU-GG-04, 1980/2004, 4CD)

by Jeff Melton, Published 2005-03-01

Scraping the Barrel Cover artThe title of this second volume of Gentle Giant audio and audiovisual archives is simply a long time fan’s obsessive labor of love. Dan Bornemark has been a charter member of the band’s on-line fan club for many years as well as a knowledgeable audio expert with access to extremely rare session outtakes, songwriting snippets, backing tracks, unreleased post band efforts and even 8MM B&W film. Discs one and two are continuations of the band’s Under Construction set that indirectly serves as a high quality proof of concept for this release. The Three Friends and The Power and the Glory recordings provide the most examples to scrutinize. Kerry Minnear’s home demos of piano parts provide enthusiastic insight as to how well developed little bits and pieces were to begin with. Gary Green’s mid-section solo on “Peel the Paint” in fact shows a bit more fluidity than the LP version in my opinion. My favorite takes are alternate version of “Mr. Class and Quality” as well as the angelic swelling vocal part and Mellotron which close out the Three Friends title track. The all instrumental version of “Think of Me with Kindness” is also quite precious. Disc three spotlights radical departure solo efforts by various members. Minnear’s eleven keyboard based songs are in a much traditional singer songwriter mode which fits quite well. Both “Home Again” and “Moog Fugue” would have been good inputs into any Giant recording effort. Plus the childlike introduction into Green and Ray Shulman’s “On Safari” is a bit of modern Duane Eddy that works. Their other two efforts are a bit of 80s modern rock much like The Fixx that is a bit dated but could have materialized into something bigger. Green’s solo guitar pieces are also pretty inspired as well. Disc four is the deep well of a fan’s odds-and-ends wish box: from rare photos of Simon Dupree with Elton John to black-and-white film of a giant walking through a miniature town. Plus some wild band rehearsals, warts and all, are presented in complete form with over eight hours of files to decipher and digest. Live performances from Plymouth and what sounds like a mixing board boot of Torino '73 sound pretty good too. The early instrumental versions of “Just the Same” and “Time to Kill” are powerful as well as the unused vibes arrangement for “On Reflection.” Overall this presents the best of the rest of the material the band has to present and I’m thankful that the archive retrieval process though arduous has been a blessing for devoted fans.

Filed under: Archives, Issue 31, 2004 releases, 1980 recordings

Related artist(s): Gentle Giant

Latest news

2017-11-16
Celebrate 10 Years of Fruits de Mer – As a special celebration for a decade of cool vinyl releases, our friends at Fruits de Mer records have prepared a limited edition reissue of an album by the first band ever to appear on the label: Schizo Fun Addict. The band is known for unusual release strag » Read more

2017-11-02
Mega Dodo Presents New Charity Album – Our friends at Mega Dodo have put together a lovely compilation of their artists performing new arrangements of nursery rhymes, and all the profits from sales of the album will benefit Save the Children. It features a number of artists we've covered. » Read more

2017-10-18
Phil Miller RIP – Sad word reaches us today of the passing of another of the great musicians of the Canterbury Scene — guitarist Phil Miller. His distinctive sound added greatly to Matching Mole, Hatfield and the North, and National Health, and he also contributed to albums by Caravan, Dave Stewart & Barbara Gaskin, and many others. He was 68. » Read more

2017-10-13
Moonjune to Distribute Tony Levin's Back Catalog – It has been announced that Moonjune will now handle distribution for Tony Levin's catalog of releases. These great albums will now be a bit easier to get hold of, so check out the site and see what you're missing. The veteran of King Crimson and Stick Men worked with a host of great players on these albums, and we've reviewed most of them over the course of the years. » Read more

2017-09-26
Bandcamp Shines Light on Niches We Like – Bandcamp has developed into one of the best places to discover new music, and even a lot of old music is showing up there. In addition, their staff has been producing periodic articles spotlighting some interesting stylistic areas. On 20 September, they published one called "The New Face of Prog Rock" which bears checking out. » Read more


Previously in Exposé...

Ozric Tentacles - Jurassic Shift – First opinion was certainly a "Wow" as it seems like Ozrics have returned to what they do best as typified on Erpland. But this album is too much like Erpland to the point that songs like "Vita Voom"...  (1993) » Read more



Listen & discover



Print issues